Selling one item on two platforms can produce two very different payouts, and the difference is rarely obvious from the headline fee. This tool puts the platforms side by side: enter your price, the shipping you charge, and the fee rates that apply to each platform, then rank them by what you actually keep.
Why the same item earns different amounts
Three things move the payout, and they are not the same on every platform:
- Who pays the fee. On some platforms the seller absorbs the commission. On others the seller is charged little or nothing and a buyer-side charge is added to the buyer's total. A "free to sell" headline describes who is charged, not whether money leaves the transaction.
- Whether shipping is included. Many platforms calculate their percentage on the whole order — the item price plus the shipping you charge — so raising your shipping figure raises the fee as well.
- Whether there is a fixed component. A flat per-order charge barely registers on a $120 item and can be the single largest deduction on a $12 one.
Because these three vary independently, the platform with the lowest headline percentage is not automatically the one that pays you most on a given sale.
How to compare platforms fairly
- Use the same order everywhere. Change one input at a time, or you end up comparing prices rather than fees.
- Enter the rates that apply to you. The defaults are editable starting points, not official numbers. Real rates depend on your country, your account, the category, and the payment method.
- Check whether the rate applies to shipping. If it does, include the shipping you charge in the price field so it is part of the calculation.
- Look at fixed fees separately on cheap items. Compare the ranking at a low price and again at a high one; it often changes.
- Re-check before you list. Fee structures change, and a comparison built last year may no longer hold.
What the two rate inputs mean
The calculator uses two numbers per platform: a percentage and a fixed amount charged per order.
- Percentage — the share of the order the platform takes. If several percentage charges apply, enter the combined figure.
- Fixed fee — the flat amount charged per order, whatever the price.
Where a platform charges the buyer rather than the seller, enter 0 for the seller-side rate. That reflects who pays, not whether a charge exists — the buyer's total is simply higher.
Worked example
Take a $30 item with $5 charged for shipping, so the buyer pays $35, and a $10 item cost. Using the default rates in the tool:
- Vinted (0%): fees $0.00 → you keep $35.00 → profit $25.00
- Mercari (10%): fees $3.50 → you keep $31.50 → profit $21.50
- Depop (10%): fees $3.50 → you keep $31.50 → profit $21.50
- Etsy (9.5% + $0.45): fees $3.78 → you keep $31.23 → profit $21.23
- eBay (13.6% + $0.30): fees $5.06 → you keep $29.94 → profit $19.94
- Poshmark (20%): fees $7.00 → you keep $28.00 → profit $18.00
The spread between the best and worst outcome is $7.00 on a single order — the same item, the same price, a different platform. On ten sales a month that is $70, which is why it is worth comparing before you list rather than after.
The ranking is also price-sensitive. Run the same comparison on a $12 item and the fixed fees take a much larger share of the order, so platforms that add a flat charge move down. Cheap items reward platforms with no fixed fee; expensive items punish high percentages.
Common mistakes
- Comparing headline percentages. A platform that charges the buyer can look free to sellers while still shaping the buyer's total. Compare the payout, not the marketing.
- Forgetting that the percentage hits shipping. If you charge $8 for shipping and the platform takes 13%, more than a dollar disappears before you have paid the courier.
- Using rates from memory. Fees differ by country, category and account level, and they change. Look them up or ask the platform.
- Leaving the fixed fee at zero. On low-priced items it is often the biggest single deduction.
- Assuming the cheapest platform is best. Payout is one factor. Audience size, how fast items sell, and the effort of listing all affect what a platform is actually worth to you.
How to use the result
- Run the comparison at two or three price points before deciding where to list a whole category of items.
- If two platforms are close, weigh the audience and the time to sell, not just the cents.
- Re-run the numbers whenever a platform announces a fee change, and keep the rate inputs up to date.
Important assumptions
The defaults are editable assumptions, not official platform rates. Fee structures differ by country, category, account type and payment method, and several platforms have moved charges between the buyer and the seller in recent years. The model does not include promoted listings, currency conversion, return costs, taxes, or subscription fees. Confirm the current rates on each platform's own fee page and enter them yourself before you make a decision.